Return to CreateDebate.comhunter8c • Join this debate community

Hunter 8C


Debate Info

23
12
Yes, it should be allowed. No, it should not be allowed.
Debate Score:35
Arguments:29
Total Votes:52
Ended:06/02/18
More Stats

Argument Ratio

side graph
 
 Yes, it should be allowed. (16)
 
 No, it should not be allowed. (11)

Debate Creator

ryan712(226) pic



This debate has ended. You can no longer add arguments or vote in this debate.

Topic #2: Should corporal punishment be allowed in schools?

Yes, it should be allowed.

Side Score: 23
Winning Side!
VS.

No, it should not be allowed.

Side Score: 12
1 point

Opening statement- We think that corporalpunish ment should be allowed.

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
1 point

1st argument- Makes kids scared of punishment

Because instead of talking back they will have an example of what is right and what is wrong and by talking back the students will get hit and eventually learn what is okay and they will learn misbehaving is bad by getting hit.

Supporting Evidence: link (www.chicagonow.com)
Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
1 point

and also getting punished for making mistakes will stop the child from redoing the same mistake or misbehaving as he will be afraid of the punishment.

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
YixiangSmart(3) Disputed
1 point

Or if a student gets angry with the punishments they received, they might start fight with the teacher

Side: No, it should not be allowed.
1 point

Closing Statement- Corporal punishment shouldbe allowed because it teaches kids what is right.

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
0 points

Argument 2-Affordable Method of Discipline

This is a very affordable way to punish a child as you wouldn’t need to visit therapists and doctors to take pills and other medicine for a misbehaving child. as a quick punishment to your child could solve many problems and save time and money.

Supporting Evidence: 10 Prevailing Pros and Cons of Corporal Punishment (nyln.org)
Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
1 point

At the same time it is very fast method and it teaches kids what is right so they will be awear of the punishments.

Supporting Evidence: link (nyln.org)
Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
1 point

And corporal punishments also make it clear on what is right and what is wrong and this will greatly help students as they get older.

Supporting Evidence: Pros and Cons of Corporal Punishment (visionlaunch.com)
Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
1 point

Closing Statement: Corporal punishments should be abolished in schools because it can harm a student's education and can have both a physical and emotional impacts on students

Side: No, it should not be allowed.
0 points

Opening Statement: Corporal punishments should not be allowed in schools

Side: No, it should not be allowed.
0 points

Corporal punishment is an inappropriate punishment that harms the education of children

Side: No, it should not be allowed.
feliper23(8) Disputed
2 points

No it does not, and it helps lot prove it. because you have no information.

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
feliper23(8) Clarified
1 point

Also there many reasons why hitting kids is fine and help.

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
YixiangSmart(3) Disputed
-1 points

The National Women's Law Center states that harsh physical punishments does not help the education of students

Supporting Evidence: This link proves this statement (www.procon.org)
Side: No, it should not be allowed.
rayan(3) Disputed
2 points

There has been many cases where corporal punishment has stop bad behaviour from reoccurring

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
0 points

Corporal punishments can have both physical and emotional impact to a student

Side: No, it should not be allowed.
feliper23(8) Disputed
2 points

It really doesn't plus the students are getting hit for a reason.

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.
0 points

the children make the trauma and Punishment affects your children's feelings of self worth.

Side: No, it should not be allowed.
0 points

Corporal punishments are also seen as a form of child abuse

Supporting Evidence: This link proves this statement (soapboxie.com)
Side: No, it should not be allowed.
-1 points

Researches has shown that children who have received corporal punishments are more likely to experience depression, low self esteem and even lead to suicide

Supporting Evidence: This link proves this statement (www.thoughtco.com)
Side: No, it should not be allowed.
rayan(3) Disputed
1 point

Children don't get depressed after one small hit to the hand and most of the time the wouldn't want to get hit again and the would start to behave and the cases that you show are form abusive teacher's as most of the time it should be a small punishment and not something the inflicts enough pain to form a bruise.

Side: Yes, it should be allowed.